By Rasha Aly

Tom Rhys Harries brings bruised humanity to James Watkins’ brisk revenge story.

Spoilers ahead for Clayface.

Clayface can become anyone. But James Watkins’ DC horror film finds its real tragedy in the one thing Matt Hagen can’t transform: his loneliness. Tom Rhys Harries gives the grotesque Gotham villain a bruised humanity, turning this revenge story into something unexpectedly tender.

Matt is a rising Hollywood star until mob boss Markos Szabo disfigures him and his career collapses. Desperate to reclaim his old life, Hagen asks scientist Dr. Caitlyn Corr to try her experimental nanocell treatment. It restores his appearance, then gives him the ability to change into other people. Matt starts using that power against the people he believes destroyed his life. The plot moves quickly, but the setup is easy to follow and the suspense builds without requiring viewers to know DC history.

The movie’s body horror lands especially well in a scene where Matt lies in a bathtub, shifting between his familiar face and a clumpy clay form. He hugs his knees to his chest as the camera moves from a wide shot toward his face. Harries lets the sadness do the work: underneath the grotesque transformation is someone grieving the life and identity he lost. The scene carries loneliness, anger, betrayal and love all at once.

Yes, love. Clayface is also a story about Matt’s longing for Dr. Corr, the scientist whose treatment gave him hope of starting over. Corr’s feelings toward him are more complicated; she’s trying to help, then has to face what her experiment has unleashed. That tension gives the revenge story an emotional thread and makes their scenes feel uneasy instead of sweet.

Harries is the movie’s anchor, but Naomi Ackie gives Dr. Corr real dimension. Her guilt and dread show in small shifts of expression as she realizes her attempt to help Matt has turned him into a danger. Ackie won the 2026 Film Independent Spirit Award for Best Supporting Performance for Sorry, Baby and the 2020 BAFTA Television Award for Supporting Actress for The End of the F***ing World.

The supporting cast includes Joshua James as Matt’s friend Corey Bowery, Eddie Marsan as his business adviser and David Dencik as mob boss Markos Szabo. Joana Ribeiro also makes an impression as Mia Torrez. Her teal satin dress and neon-lit introduction gave me a flash of Michelle Pfeiffer’s Elvira Hancock in Scarface; Ribeiro brings a classic femme-fatale edge to the role.

One of the movie’s strengths is its pace. Watkins gets to the origin quickly and keeps the story moving through visceral set pieces and turns of revenge. Clayface is easy to follow even for viewers without a DC background, which makes it a welcoming entry point for new fans.

Among the new DCU’s first three theatrical releases, my ranking is Superman first, Clayface next, and Supergirl third. I found Clayface more enjoyable than Supergirl, but Superman is still the stronger film for me. Watkins gives this one its own horror identity, and Harries makes the monster feel human enough to stay with you after the gore is over.

Fans looking for suspense, body horror and a new angle on a DC villain should give Clayface a watch. It may not top Superman, but it has a distinctive voice and a compelling lead performance that make it well worth seeing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *